Is it unconscionable to encourage someone with dementia to sign a binding financial agreement?

by Andrew Lind on 14 June, 17


Teh & Muir [2017] FamCA

In this case, a guardian for Mr Muir sought to have the Binding Financial Agreement set aside under s 90UM(1)(h) on the basis that Ms Teh had engaged in conduct which was unconscionable.

Conduct will be unconscionable if:

  • The weaker person is at a special disadvantage that affects the person’s ability to protect his or her own interests; and
  • The stronger party knows or ought to know of the special disadvantage; and
  • The stronger person takes advantage of the special disadvantage by allowing the agreement to proceed: The Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Amadio (1983) 151 CLR 447 per Gibbs CJ at [459]).

A special disadvantage might include: poverty or need of any kind; sickness; age; illiteracy or lack of education; or lack of assistance or explanation where assistance or explanation was required: Blomley v Ryan (1956) 99 CLR 362.

In this case, Mr Muir was suffering from a significant disadvantage, namely dementia and Alzheimer’s disease. Ms Teh was aware of this and encouraged him to sign the Agreement for her own financial advantage.

The Agreement was set aside.


It may be considered unconscionable to encourage a person suffering from impaired mental capacity to enter into a Binding Financial Agreement.

{ 0 comments… add one now }

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



Terms & Conditions

Law Experts content including responses to your questions and comments provides legal information, tips and hints. The content on this site is not legal advice. That’s good, because there’s no risk of getting a bill by making a comment, asking a question or just contacting us.

You agree that any comment or question that you may ask may be published on this site, after editorial review, for the benefit of future readers. Our editors may edit comments in their discretion. For example we will would seek to remove information that would identify you.

The Corney & Lind lawyers (law experts) are of course happy to give legal advice, that’s what they do for a living. However it is only legal advice when you have engaged Corney & Lind Lawyers to provide legal advice for you. Before you do that you want to have an idea of what it might cost and our lawyers are happy to communicate with you about this.

We may change any of these terms and conditions at any time in our discretion by changing them on this page.

You must scroll down the terms & conditions before you can agree.

Previous post:

Next post: